Some NBA players are just not meant to be the number 1 player on their teams. You can try it out and hope that it works but it will never win you a championship, and I’m betting that it also will not help you get too far in the playoffs (if you can even get that far).
Deron Williams, PG, New Jersey Nets. (Career: 17.2 PPG, 9.2 Assists, 3.2 Rebounds) Williams is obviously one of the top point guards in the game, hands down. He most likely ranks in the top 5 for that position but I am not sold on the fact that he could be the number one guy on a team. Until this season, he had been leading the Utah Jazz and the team had successfully fought in the Western Conference but unfortunately could never make it too far in the playoffs. I considered D-Will the lead man for that Jazz team with Carlos Boozer as his number 2, somewhat similar to how Derrick Rose has it right now. Although the team may have not been fully constructed to win a championship, it definitely consisted of many great, talented players. There was no real excuse for why Deron Williams could not lead that team deep into the playoffs besides the fact that he did not have D’ Will…get it?
Andre Iguodala, SF, Philadelphia 76ers. (Career: 15.6 PPG, 4.8 Assists, 5.8 Rebounds) After Allen Iverson was traded during the 2006-2007 season, the new “AI” was expected to take over and become the leader of the team. Over the next few years, Iguodala’s numbers were close to 20 PPG, 5 assists and 5 rebounds, but the Sixers were straight struggling. They have been able to make some playoff appearances but they have all been just to get knocked out of the first round. The acquisition of Elton Brand was supposed to help bring support for Iggy but only until this past season has Brand even shown up. Iguodala is a beast of a dunker (and should of won the 2006 NBA Dunk Contest) and has become one of the top wing defenders in the league, but he does not seem to possess the number 1 player quality. This is quite hard for me to say, as a 76ers and Andre Iguodala fan, but Iggy doesn’t have that second gear that he can turn on during the playoffs. His first gear is actually not even good enough to be considered a cornerstone player of a team. I believe the Sixers know this and therefore drafted Evan Turner to try and fill that void but unfortunately his rookie season did not live up to the high expectations.
Danny Granger, SF, Indiana Pacers. (Career: 18.2 PPG, 2.1 Assists, 5.3 Rebounds) In my opinion, Granger is a very interesting case. During the two seasons from 2008-2010, Granger averaged over 24 PPG and brought in over 5 rebounds per game, numbers that fell just a little short of those put up by Carmelo Anthony. Granger has not had too great of a squad around him but many other stars have been able to take their do-little rosters and make a playoff push, so why so different with Granger? Plain and simple, he does not have what it takes to put a team on his back and lead them to victory.
Joe Johnson, SF, Atlanta Hawks. (Career: 17.7 PPG, 4.5 Assists, 4.2 Rebounds) I am actually a little shocked by these numbers. I had always assumed that Joe Johnson was a big time scorer and although he did average over 25 during one season and has been around 21 for the past few years, it is nothing too impressive compared to what I had imagined. Johnson is an all-around player, very similar to Iguodala, except that he has a pretty good 3-point shot and just got a huge contract for about $119 millions over six years. Yes, it has been discussed many times already…what were the Hawks thinking? Unlike all the other players that are mentioned on this list, Joe Johnson is not only expected and seen as the number 1 player on the team but he is PAID like a number 1 player. He, out of all these other players, should be able to lead his team in the same way that Kobe, Rose, LeBron and Wade do. Although the Hawks have been having some success as of late, it is more of a collective effort rather than Joe Johnson taking this team on his back.
Rudy Gay, SF, Memphis Grizzlies. (Career: 17.8 PPG, 1.9 Assists, 5.6 Rebounds) The Grizzlies are obviously succeeding in the playoffs without him, so that in itself is a true argument that Gay cannot be considered a cornerstone player. The only reason I have still included him in this list is that he is being payed like one of the top players and definitely as the top player on that team. This past summer he signed a contract for over $80 million over 5 years…yeah, the player who is not even involved in their recent playoff success!
So these are some of the top players that I would include in my “Robin League.” They are great players, don’t get me wrong, but they just do not have what it takes to be Batman. I do like seeing LeBron James and Dwayne Wade on one team but these “Robins” are the type of players that they needed to pair up with to keep things more entertaining and competitive. Some past “Robins” that have found success in teaming up with a true Batman are Pau Gasol, Ray Allen and now Chris Bosh…although while LeBron and Wade fight for the Batman spot, he will have to settle for being Commissioner Jim Gordon.



























