Does LA deserve professional football and which team (Jacksonville, Oakland, Minnesota, San Diego, St. Louis) should move there? The PMB staff weighed in…
Zayd Sharif: Being a big football fan this is a really hard question to not be biased about. LA already lost two teams and now people want another one. But as long as the stadium is made in a great location and things are properly handled then yes we do deserve a football team in this city. The Raiders have the largest fan base out of those 4 teams in the region so plenty of people would be happy if the Raiders came. Problem is a lot won’t be happy. The Chargers might need a change of scenery to maybe push them over the edge and actually win a title… The Vikings I do not think will move here because there are moves in place to keep them in Minnesota if they get a new stadium. Jacksonville would actually be interesting because they are a team that is rebuilding and trying to find a quarterback but I think a team that is trying to find itself is a good team to move because then a city can bond with that team and although have to deal with growing pains and a few losing seasons I will reveal true fans that will back that team. Real fans in Los Angeles do exist, but when it comes to Lakers games it just too expensive to go a lot. So if LA wants to deserve a football team it has to cater to the fans who care and want to go out there and cheer for their team.
Anand Patel: I actually do not believe that Los Angeles deserves a football team. The LA/OC area currently has two baseball teams, two (and maybe three in the future) basketball teams and two hockey teams. Along with the professional teams, LA has two highly competitive collegiate sports programs in USC and UCLA. Although the USC football team has been going through a few down years, I still believe that they are the football team of LA. It sure seemed like it during their good years. When it comes down to it, the LA/OC area already has too many sports teams in my opinions and adding more teams is not going to help some of the already struggling franchises already there.
But they will most likely get a team and they are preparing themselves for it. If I had to pick a team to move to LA, it would be the Raiders. This mainly has to do with the fact that they already have a following in LA seeing that they were previously from there. You know what team it shouldn’t be? The San Diego Chargers! As a Charger fan and San Diego native, I will be extremely pissed off if they move to LA and yes, the constant blackout scares and underachieving seasons do not help, but the Chargers belong in San Diego. The Padres are an average team and we need something to be proud of, even if they never live up to expectations. If the Chargers do end up moving to LA, I sure as hell will only support them for a few more years or until Philip Rivers is done playing for them. Plus, which Oakland Raider fan that lives in LA wants the division rival Chargers moving into town? It’s absurd, so LA should take back the Raiders and leave the Chargers alone.
Ryan Dunn: The question of whether L.A. deserves football is easy. Absolutely. The Raiders left back for Oakland after Satan Al Davis didn’t get a new stadium. The Rams and Georgia Frontiere left because the Rams were in a funk and she wanted more money. While it’s easy to say fans didn’t support the team, it makes it hard to support a team playing bad and with an owner that’s despised. Ask Frank McCourt and the Dodgers. And now there is a new football stadium planned. There may even be two. The city is crazy about USC (corrupt program) and UCLA (awful program) so if there is an honest to god pro team that’s relatively competitive, what’s stopping support of an NFL team?
As for the team, I don’t think L.A. want’s another go around with the Raiders. East L.A. may, but if Al Davis is involved, there is no way anyone wants to deal with him. Especially AEG, who is likely to be calling some shots as they are building a stadium and driving the relocation push. The Bills had their names kicked around, but no way Buffalo lets them go. The Vikings are struggling, need a new stadium, and have a city connected to L.A. already with sports, aka, the Lakers. Hell, even the Vikings’ colors fit the scheme of the Lakers and the Kings from their early years. But I think Minnesota fights tooth and nail to keep them. The Rams were also proposed, and they are a team rid of their past owner and with a relatively large L.A. fan base still. I have to think the chances for the Rams are about the third best to relocate. But the two most likely are either the Jaguars or Chargers.
Jacksonville just cannot fill their stadium. They don’t have much of a franchise history, and common sense based off those logistics alone puts them in position likely to move. And they likely will. If the Chargers and Alex Spanos don’t leave San Diego that is. Now, without sounding like I am some sort of super insider with special knowledge, AEG, from the time I worked for them, has had their sights set on the Chargers for a while. This was spring in 2010, and during their companywide meeting they leaked to their employees the idea of building a stadium next to the Staples Center. Less than a month later the AEG sales groups all began focusing on selling tickets for the Chargers…in Los Angeles. It certainly seemed like AEG was testing the L.A. market with the Chargers, or at least to the idea of a pro football team again.
I’m all for football in L.A. It’s the second biggest market in the country and has had teams prior. I’d prefer if it were the Jaguars because they make the most sense. But it’s most likely going to be the Chargers.
Avi Shah: LA absolutely deserves a football team. A lot of people make the argument that they don’t because both the Rams and the Raiders left LA in 1994, but this is a different era we are talking about. The popularity of football has increased in LA as it has all across the US with the rising popularity of things like fantasy football, DirectTV’s Sunday Ticket, NFL Network, and NFL Red Zone. Just the rise of USC is a clear example of the love of football in this city. They fill the LA Coliseum with 70,000 every time they have a home game, and I think an NFL team could have the same impact with the 63,000 capacity of the proposed Farmers Field. Also just yesterday, Gov. Jerry Brown passed legislation to speed up the process of the objection period. The city is hungry for jobs as well, and having a team play in Farmers Field would definitely help out local businesses and provide jobs. I think the San Diego Chargers are the most likely team to be playing in LA in 2013. The citizens of San Diego want no part in funding for a new stadium downtown. AEG also wants 33% ownership of the team, and the Chargers out of the list are the ones in position to give up that much. There are plenty of Chargers fans in LA already as the team is only 100 miles away, so filling the stadium would be easy.
Amish Doshi: Should LA have a football team? Sure, economically it makes sense and everyone living here knows how badly the city is hurting for a major revenue stream to support its shrinking general fund. Do they deserve one? I don’t believe they do. Los Angeles right now has the Lakers, Dodgers, Angels, UCLA & USC football (Don’t even try to say that the Angels aren’t considered part of Los Angeles…we all know they are considered a part of it when they are WINNING). LA lost two football teams, not one, two. Listening to sports talk radio for the last 3 months about this issue has led me to one conclusion…people want football in Los Angeles BUT so they can see the games. There is no talk about any desire to latch on to a new franchise and embrace it as their own. It’s about GOING TO SEE PROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL. Does that mean the same thing as supporting your franchise? Hmm this sounds familiar to the 30 dopey fans (who actually knew what was going on) in Orange County who were so excited to not have to DRIVE 1-2 hours to go watch the Lakers play at Staples when there were talks of the Sacramento Kings moving to Anaheim … Does this make a city/region truly deserve a professional sports team?
I would be an idiot if I said sports were only about the FANS. Because they clearly aren’t and its moved more and more away from being about the fans. You can point to a number of factors that have changed over the last 2 or 3 generations. The money has changed everything in my opinion. Being self-serving, tv deals, star teams or players, jumping on the bandwagon and having a “great market” has become the overriding reasons for throwing away 30+ years of history in one city and jumping to another area. When does this s— ever stop? If you want to put a football team in LA…great! I think it will make a lot of money for your league overall but at least let the fans demonstrate they want THEIR OWN TEAM first. I don’t see any evidence of it period. You’ve got Cowboys fans, Steelers fans, Eagles fans, Niners fans, Raiders fans, Giants fans and the list goes on all over this spread out region. No one is going to TRULY support a singular team. I don’t believe it. The only team I see with any consistent following right now are the Lakers because they NEVER STOP winning. Football can succeed in ALL markets, not just big ones. Why should a franchise that has major roots such as the Chargers in San Diego be moved? (Sidenote: SHAME ON THE ENTIRE CITY OF SAN DIEGO AND ITS POLITICIANS FOR NOT DOING ONE DAMN THING TO STOP IT, DESPITE STILL HAVING TIME AND SHAME ON ALL THE LOCAL SPORTSWRITERS/BLOGGERS FOR NOT DOING ONE DAMN THING http://www.boltsfromtheblue.com/2010/12/1/1848753/are-the-chargers-moving-to-los-angeles )
All in all, I don’t believe LA deserves a football team because they won’t truly understand how to appreciate it because they have so many options to choose from that if its not winning…who cares? Are they going to get one? Yes and it should be the Jacksonville Jaguars in my opinion. They are in the worst economic situation of any team (see random decision to cut David Garrard and blackouts) and their fans have stopped showing up to the games along with the fact that they have the least amount of franchise history associated with their city. But obviously its not going to happen because San Diego seems to have accepted the loss of their team. No grassroots movements, nothing even in the paper talking about trying to keep the team. Pathetic and I feel bad for Anand Patel because its not fair to the true fans…unfortunately sports is not about them anymore. It’s about money.


























